If you’re planning a visit to New Smyrna Beach and are a pizza lover, you’re in for a treat. This charming beach town boasts an array of pizza restaurants that cater to all tastes. Whether you prefer a classic New York-style slice or a gourmet pizza with creative toppings, NSB has something for everyone. Here’s a guide to some of the best pizza places in New Smyrna Beach.

1. Panheads Pizzeria

Located on South Orange Street, Panheads Pizzeria is a family-owned gem known for its delicious, homemade pizzas. The restaurant prides itself on using the freshest ingredients, and their menu features a variety of unique pizzas like the “Grease Monkey” with pepperoni, sausage, and bacon, and the “Sturgis” with barbecue chicken and caramelized onions. Panheads also offers a selection of pasta dishes, salads, and their famous cheese breadsticks, making it a great spot for a hearty meal.

2. Prima Pizza Cucina

Prima Pizza Cucina, situated on Sams Avenue, offers an upscale pizza dining experience. This restaurant is perfect for a date night or a special occasion, with a menu that includes a range of gourmet pizzas, antipasti, and a curated wine selection. The “Margherita” and “Pesto Chicken” pizzas are particularly popular. Prima’s elegant ambiance and excellent service make it a standout choice for pizza enthusiasts.

3. Manny’s Pizza

A staple in New Smyrna Beach for over thirty years, Manny’s Pizza on South Atlantic Avenue is beloved for its nostalgic atmosphere and delicious pies. The restaurant features a casual dining area with a pool table and arcade games, making it a fun spot for families. Manny’s offers a variety of traditional pizzas, Italian dishes, and their famous Greek salad. It’s a go-to place for those looking for a relaxed dining experience with a bit of 90s charm.

4. Flagler Avenue Pizza Company

As the name suggests, Flagler Avenue Pizza Company is located on the bustling Flagler Avenue. This pizzeria is known for its New York-style pizza with wide slices, great sauce, and a crispy crust. Popular choices include the “Great White” and the classic “Margherita.” The rooftop dining area provides a fantastic view of Flagler Avenue, making it a great spot to enjoy your pizza while soaking in the local vibe.

5. Caffé Vesuvio

Caffé Vesuvio on East 3rd Avenue offers a delightful Italian dining experience. Known for its wood-fired pizzas and traditional Italian dishes, this restaurant has something for everyone. Try their “Pepperoni Pizza” or “Margherita Pizza,” and don’t miss the garlic knots and tiramisu for dessert. The cozy atmosphere and friendly service make Caffé Vesuvio a favorite among locals and visitors alike.

6. Beachside Pizza

Beachside Pizza, recently opened by locals Martin and Jamie, is located on South Atlantic Avenue. This family-friendly restaurant is committed to serving high-quality, locally-sourced ingredients. Beachside Pizza offers a range of pizzas and other Italian favorites in a welcoming environment. The new owners’ deep connection to the location and community makes this a special spot to visit.

7. Stavros Pizzeria and Restaurant

Stavros Pizzeria and Restaurant, situated on North Dixie Freeway, has been a local favorite for over 30 years. This restaurant offers a wide variety of pizzas, along with Greek and Italian dishes. The laid-back atmosphere and friendly service make it a great place to enjoy a meal with family and friends. Popular menu items include their hand-tossed pizzas and famous Greek salads.

Enjoy Your Pizza Experience with New Smyrna Stays

When planning your visit to New Smyrna Beach, consider staying with New Smyrna Stays. They offer a variety of comfortable and luxurious rental options that are perfect for families, couples, and solo travelers. With beachfront condos and spacious vacation homes, New Smyrna Stays ensures you have a relaxing and memorable stay. Each rental is equipped with modern amenities and is conveniently located near all the best pizza restaurants in NSB, making it easy for you to explore the culinary delights of this charming beach town.

Start planning your pizza adventure today with New Smyrna Stays and discover the delicious offerings of New Smyrna Beach. From traditional pizzerias to gourmet pizza spots, NSB has everything you need for a perfect pizza-filled vacation.